England enjoy productive day as they dismiss half the New Zealand side on day one of the third Test - before Daryl Mitchell leads tourists' fightback in final session following extraordinary dismissal of Henry Nicholls

  • Henry Nicholls suffered one of the most extraordinary dismissals in Test history
  • It came on another productive day for Ben Stokes and his men at Headingley 
  • But Daryl Mitchell is still there even though he should have been given out 
  • That was the only blemish for an England side determined to be positive again

For once Ben Stokes was happy to see the ball come off the middle of Daryl Mitchell's bat as it led to one of the most extraordinary dismissals in Test history on another productive day for England.

Mitchell, who has enjoyed a prolific series since his late promotion ahead of the first Test, was actually the non-striker when Henry Nicholls hit Jack Leach firmly back towards him on the stroke of tea on the first day of this final LV = Insurance match.

But such is his golden form he could not seem to avoid in his attempt to get out of the way almost driving the ball to the disbelieving figure of Alex Lees at mid-off. He completed a simple catch while Leach and England's fielders tried to work out what had happened.

New Zealand suffered a bizarre dismissal on the first day of the third Test against England

New Zealand suffered a bizarre dismissal on the first day of the third Test against England

Henry Nicholls (not pictured) was dismissed after his shot off Jack Leach (centre) ricocheted off the bat of Daryl Mitchell (right)

Henry Nicholls (not pictured) was dismissed after his shot off Jack Leach (centre) ricocheted off the bat of Daryl Mitchell (right)

The ball then looped to the disbelieving figure of England's Alex Lees (left) at mid-off

The ball then looped to the disbelieving figure of England's Alex Lees (left) at mid-off

Cue a look of astonishment from Stuart Broad, who put his hand to his mouth in similar style to his famous reaction when Stokes pulled off an incredible catch off his bowling at Trent Bridge seven years ago. Everything, it seems, is going England's way.


Not quite everything as, by the end of another absorbing day at Headingley, Mitchell was still there even though he should have been given out lbw by Matthew Potts.

Mitchell, a century maker both at Lord's and Trent Bridge, was on just eight when Potts trapped him seemingly plumb in front only for umpire Marais Erasmus to say no.

Stokes looked certain to review only for Ben Foakes to talk him out of it, suggesting the ball was going down the leg-side. It was not. It would have hit middle.

Mitchell was still there at the end, but should have been given out lbw to Matthew Potts (front)

Mitchell was still there at the end, but should have been given out lbw to Matthew Potts (front)

Ben Stokes (left) looked certain to review only for Ben Foakes to talk him out of doing so

Ben Stokes (left) looked certain to review only for Ben Foakes to talk him out of doing so

Stuart Broad got the wicket of opener Tom Latham in the first over of the match at Headingley

Stuart Broad got the wicket of opener Tom Latham in the first over of the match at Headingley

That was the only blemish for an England side who were determined to be just as positive and attacking in the field as they have been with the bat in already winning this series after Kane Williamson won what seemed an important toss.

From the moment Broad, enjoying a new lease of life under Stokes captaincy, took Tom Latham's edge with the sixth ball of the day this was another impressive performance from the new England on a flat pitch in what were largely perfect batting conditions.

At the centre of it was Stokes even though he did not bowl a ball as New Zealand finished on 225 for five, the old firm of Mitchell and Tom Blundell again combining to hold up England and rescue their side with an unbroken stand of 102 for the sixth wicket.

It has taken just two matches for Stokes to be absolutely in command of an England side transformed by the leadership of their captain and new coach Brendon McCullum.

Broad then enticed an edge from returning skipper Kane Williamson, who departed for 31

Broad then enticed an edge from returning skipper Kane Williamson, who departed for 31

Spinner Jack Leach trapped Will Young lbw for 20 in a decent morning session for England

Spinner Jack Leach trapped Will Young lbw for 20 in a decent morning session for England

Here Stokes backed his bowlers, gave them attacking fields, made perfectly timed changes to the attack and always looked in command and in control of what was happening on the field. Truly, everything he is touching in this job so far is turning to gold.

No-one benefited more from the captain's support on Thursday than Leach, who came into this Test with much to prove to keep his place as England's premier spinner. Not least with Moeen Ali and Adil Rashid now apparently 'unretired' from red-ball cricket.

Stokes introduced the left-armer, a cult figure in Leeds after his supporting role with the bat in the 2019 Miracle of Headingley, as early as the 13th over and was rewarded when he trapped Will Young with his very first delivery.

It was just the eighth wicket Leach has taken in the first innings of a Test but by the time he took his ninth, with considerable help from that deflection, he had produced a controlled display laced with attack not spoilt by the two sixes struck off him by Mitchell.

England debutant Jamie Overton (R) got his first Test match wicket in the afternoon session

England debutant Jamie Overton (R) got his first Test match wicket in the afternoon session 

New Zealand batsman Devon Conway inside-edged the ball straight onto his stumps

New Zealand batsman Devon Conway inside-edged the ball straight onto his stumps 

In all there were 37 overs of spin from Leach and Joe Root on a ground usually associated with first day swing, Leach even returning with the second new ball, with Stokes insisting he was fit to bowl despite the knee problem he had suffered at Trent Bridge.

Stokes similarly handled his debutant in Jamie Overton well, giving him a defined role with the old ball and introducing him at the right times, not least when the third ball of his second spell, this time from the Kirkstall Lane End, brought his first Test wicket.

It was appropriate, too, that the younger of the twins from Barnstaple by three minutes dismissed a man called Devon, taking advantage of Conway's penchant for inside edging to have him bowled via bat with a ball timed at 87 miles per hour. 'Older' brother Craig emerged on the England balcony to add his applause for his sibling.

Overton regularly bowled in the late 80s, peaking at 90, seemed to trouble the New Zealand batters with his short deliveries and looked the point of difference England so badly need in the absence of the extreme pace of Mark Wood and Jofra Archer. Only when he bowled a full-toss, near beamer to Mitchell that flew for four byes did Overton err.

Nicholls was then forced to walk back after his strange dismissal just before the tea break

Nicholls was then forced to walk back after his strange dismissal just before the tea break

Mitchell however steadied the ship and brought up his half-century in the evening session

Mitchell however steadied the ship and brought up his half-century in the evening session

Potts was also excellent and economical but the pick of the attack was Broad, who announced on Wednesday night he is expecting his first child with partner Mollie King and now rose to the extra responsibility caused by the absence of his old strike partner Jimmy Anderson, as he invariably does.

'He's big, he's bad, he's going to be a dad,' sang the Barmy Army in a revised version of their homage to Broad and the man who turns 36 on Friday followed his early wicket of Latham by dismissing Williamson with a beautifully set up piece of bowling.

Broad bowled an inswinger to the out of touch New Zealand captain and followed it up with one that shaped away from the returning Williamson and took his edge. Another failure for a world-class batter who is having a miserable time in Test cricket and 548 Test wicket and counting for Broad.

While Mitchell and Blundell are still there New Zealand could post a formidable total and they have packed their team with batting while, inexplicably, leaving out specialist spinner Ajaz Patel. But it will be Stokes and England who will be happier after day one.

While Mitchell and Tom Blundell (R) are still there New Zealand could post a formidable total

While Mitchell and Tom Blundell (R) are still there New Zealand could post a formidable total

But it will be Stokes and England who will be happier after day one of this Test match

But it will be Stokes and England who will be happier after day one of this Test match

The comments below have not been moderated.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.