Skip to content
NOWCAST Pittsburgh's Action News 4 at Noon
Live Now
Advertisement

Clear encampment or face suspension, Columbia University tells Israel-Hamas war protesters

Clear encampment or face suspension, Columbia University tells Israel-Hamas war protesters
STORIES RIGHT NOW ON MATTER OF FACT. MORE THAN 5000 MILES FROM ISRAEL IN GAZA, DEMONSTRATORS HAVE SET UP CAMP AT SOME OF THE MOST PROMINENT UNIVERSITIES IN THE UNITED STATES. COLLEGES ARE OBVIOUSLY NO STRANGERS TO PROTESTS, AND THEY’RE USED TO THE EXCHANGE OF DIFFERING IDEAS. AND THAT’S WHAT PROFESSORS AT DARTMOUTH COLLEGE ARE LEANING INTO. THEIR CO-TEACHING COURSES THEY HOPE INSPIRE DEEP UNDERSTANDING AND NUANCED DEBATE AMONG STUDENTS ABOUT THE MIDDLE EAST’S PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE. OUR CORRESPONDENT LEONE LAKHANI TAKES US TO CLASS. THE CRISP SPRING DAY BRINGS STUDENTS OUT AT DARTMOUTH COLLEGE IN NEW HAMPSHIRE, BUT TWO OF ITS TEACHERS ARE INSIDE PREPARING. FOR A UNIQUE CLASS. PROFESSOR TARIQ RICE IS THE HEAD OF THE MIDDLE EASTERN STUDIES DEPARTMENT. PROFESSOR SUSANNAH HESCHEL, CHAIR OF JEWISH STUDIES. ONCE A WEEK, THEY COME TOGETHER TO CO-TEACH A CLASS, CREATING WHAT THEY CALL A SCHOLARLY EXCHANGE. WHAT CREATES THE SILENCE? THE CLASS COVERS 18TH TO 20TH CENTURY HISTORY, PIVOTAL PERIODS, THEY SAY, FOR BOTH -- AND ARABS IN THE ARABIC CONTEXT, A LOT OF THE WOMEN, THE FEMINIST. ARTS WERE EMBRACING SOME FORM OF EUROPEAN MODERNITY. THE PROFESSORS WEAVE IN AND OUT OF EACH OTHER’S TALKS, WHICH SCRIPTURE SAYS WOMEN SHOULD WEAR A VEIL. YOU TESTAMENT. THE NEW TESTAMENT, BUT NOT THE KORAN, NOT THE HEBREW BIBLE. THEY DELVE INTO IDEOLOGIES LIKE FORMS OF ARAB NATIONALISM AND ZIONISM TO HELP STUDENTS HAVE A DEEPER UNDERSTANDING OF TENSIONS IN THE REGION. I WANT THEM TO UNDERSTAND THE SHARED PROBLEMS THAT WE HAVE FACED AS -- AND AS ARABS, AND LOOK AT SOME OF THE SIMILAR RESPONSES WE FORMULATED. SO WE WANT TO ALSO OFFER A MODEL OF, OF OF CONVIVENCE. YES. THAT DOES NOT REQUIRE THAT ONE ELIMINATES THE OTHER, THAT THERE IS ROOM FOR SOME FORM OF COMMUNAL COEXISTENCE. THE PROFESSORS CREATED THIS CLASS THREE YEARS AGO AND THERE ARE OTHER CO-TAUGHT CLASSES BETWEEN THESE DEPARTMENTS, BUT THEY TOOK ON NEW IMPORTANCE AFTER THE OCTOBER 7TH ATTACKS ON ISRAEL AND THE ENSUING WAR IN GAZA. HOW DO YOU THINK THIS KNOWLEDGE WILL HELP PEOPLE UNDERSTAND AND NAVIGATE THE EVENTS OF TODAY? OUR JOB IS REALLY TO EXPAND THEIR HORIZON AND MAKE SURE THAT THEY’RE GETTING THIS WIDE VIEW THAT GOES INTO THE PAST, AND IT’S NOT LIMITED ONLY TO WHAT WE ARE SEEING ON TV OR ON SOCIAL MEDIA. AND THEN THEY CAN MAKE THEIR OWN, YOU KNOW, POLITICAL CHOICES AND DEVELOP THEIR OWN VIEWS AND ENGAGE THE WORLD IN THE WAY THAT THEY SEE FIT. THE EVENTS OF OCTOBER 7TH AND THE WAR SINCE ARE PARTICULARLY SIGNIFICANT IN THIS CONFLICT. THAT’S 70 PLUS YEARS, AND IT’S POLARIZING. A LOT OF PEOPLE. EL WHAT DO YOU SAY TO THEM WHEN THERE ARE TWO WAYS OF LOOKING AT IT? ON THE ONE HAND, IT’S A MOMENT OF CRISIS, BUT IT’S ALSO A MOMENT OF GREAT, GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR OUR THINKING IN A WAY THAT ACKNOWLEDGES WHAT’S HAPPENING IN THE WORLD. BUT AT THE SAME TIME, MAKE SURE THAT THEY’RE GETTING THE EDUCATION THAT WE THINK IS ESSENTIAL FOR THEM. STUDENTS I SPOKE TO WHO TAKE THE CLASS, SAY IT’S WIDENING THEIR PERSPECTIVES BECAUSE IT TALKS ABOUT BOTH EUROPE AND BOTH THE MIDDLE EAST, ESPECIALLY IN THE CURRENT CONTEXT. I WANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT, UM, THE JEWISH IDENTITY, THE PALESTINIAN IDENTITY AND EVERYTHING. I FEEL LIKE STUDENTS THESE DAYS KNOW FAR LESS HISTORY, FAR LESS BACKGROUND THAN PERHAPS WE SHOULD IN ORDER TO GET A REAL COMPREHENSIVE VIEW OF WHAT THE CURRENT CONFLICT, WHATEVER IT IS. IN SOME WAYS I THINK THERE’S A LOT MORE STUDY YOU NEED TO DO, AND UNTIL YOU CAN REALLY. SAY, I HAVE THIS OPINION BECAUSE OF SORT OF MY DEEP KNOWLEDGE OF OF THE HISTORY, BUILDING A DEEP KNOWLEDGE OF THE HISTORY AND THE PRESENT, WHERE A WAVE OF PROTESTS IS SWEEPING ACROSS SOME COLLEGE CAMPUSES AT DARTMOUTH, THEY’VE BEEN A SMALLER SCALE AND IN THE IMMEDIATE WAKE OF OCTOBER 7TH, THESE PROFESSORS TOOK THEIR CO-TEACHING MODEL AND MADE IT AVAILABLE TO THE ENTIRE STUDENT BODY BY HOLDING PUBLIC FORUMS. HOW DO YOU RECOMMEND THAT WE VOICE OUR DISAGREEMENT? I, I UNDERSTAND THAT EMOTIONS ARE HIGH. I KNOW EVERYBODY OWNS SEINER ATTENDED A FORUM. HE’S ALSO A STUDENT IN THE CLASS. AND SAYS IT HELPS TO BREAK STEREOTYPES. I FEEL LIKE A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE PRONE TO PUTTING ARABS AND -- IN VERY SEPARATE BOXES. AND LIKE IN DOING SO, THEY IGNORE A LOT OF SHARED HISTORY AND SHARED UNDERSTANDING. PROFESSOR HESHEL AND ALLERY SAY OTHER INSTITUTIONS ARE APPROACHING THEM ABOUT THEIR MODEL. WE’VE BEEN ASKED TO CONSULT WITH A LOT OF COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES AND ALSO PROFESSIONAL SOCIETIES, WHERE THERE’S A TERRIBLE POLARIZATION, AND THEY ASK US FOR ADVICE, ADVICE THAT COULD CREATE GREATER UNDERSTANDING EVEN BEYOND THEIR OWN CAMPUS FOR MATTER OF FACT,
Advertisement
Clear encampment or face suspension, Columbia University tells Israel-Hamas war protesters
Colleges around the country implored pro-Palestinian student protesters to clear out tent encampments with rising levels of urgency Monday, including an ultimatum from Columbia University for students to sign a form and leave the encampment by the afternoon or face suspension.College classes nationwide are wrapping up for the semester, and campuses are preparing for graduation ceremonies.The notice sent by Columbia to protesters in the encampment Monday said that if they leave by the designated time and sign a form committing to abide by university policies through June 2025 or an earlier graduation, they can finish the semester in good standing. If not, the letter said, they will be suspended, pending further investigation.“We urge you to remove the encampment so that we do not deprive your fellow students, their families and friends of this momentous occasion,” the letter said, noting that exams are beginning and graduation is upcoming at the Ivy League university in New York City.A spokesperson for Columbia confirmed the letter had gone out to students but declined to comment further.Mahmoud Khalil, the lead negotiator on behalf of protesters, said university representatives began passing out the notices at the encampment shortly after 10 a.m. Monday. He said discussions were ongoing about how to proceed.Early protests at Columbia, where demonstrators set up tents in the center of the campus, sparked pro-Palestinian demonstrations across the country. Students and others have been sparring over the Israel-Hamas war and its mounting death toll. Many students are demanding their universities cut financial ties with Israel.About 275 people were arrested Saturday at various campuses including Indiana University at Bloomington, Arizona State University and Washington University in St. Louis. The number of arrests nationwide has surpassed 900 since New York police removed a pro-Palestinian protest encampment at Columbia and arrested more than 100 demonstrators on April 18.The demonstrations at Columbia have led it to hold remote classes and set a series of deadlines for protesters to leave the encampment, which they have missed. The school said in an email to students that bringing back police “at this time” would be counterproductive.The students and administrators have negotiated to end the disruptions, but the sides have not come to an agreement, university President Minouche Shafik said in a statement Monday. Protests were still active at a number of campuses. Near George Washington University, protesters at an encampment breached and dismantled the barriers Monday morning used to secure University Yard, the university said in a statement. The yard had been closed since last week.Protesters at Yale University set up a new encampment with dozens of tents Sunday afternoon, nearly a week after police arrested nearly 50 demonstrators and cleared a similar camp.At least one school, the University of Southern California, canceled its main graduation ceremony this spring. Others are asking the protests to resolve peacefully so they can hold their ceremonies.Protesters on both sides shouted and shoved each other during dueling demonstrations Sunday at the University of California, Los Angeles. The university stepped up security after “some physical altercations broke out among demonstrators,” Mary Osako, vice chancellor for UCLA Strategic Communications, said in a statement. There were no reports of arrests or injuries.The plight of students who have been arrested has become a central part of protests, with the students and a growing number of faculty demanding amnesty for protesters. At issue is whether the suspensions and legal records will follow students through their adult lives.

Colleges around the country implored pro-Palestinian student protesters to clear out tent encampments with rising levels of urgency Monday, including an ultimatum from Columbia University for students to sign a form and leave the encampment by the afternoon or face suspension.

College classes nationwide are wrapping up for the semester, and campuses are preparing for graduation ceremonies.

Advertisement

The notice sent by Columbia to protesters in the encampment Monday said that if they leave by the designated time and sign a form committing to abide by university policies through June 2025 or an earlier graduation, they can finish the semester in good standing. If not, the letter said, they will be suspended, pending further investigation.

“We urge you to remove the encampment so that we do not deprive your fellow students, their families and friends of this momentous occasion,” the letter said, noting that exams are beginning and graduation is upcoming at the Ivy League university in New York City.

A spokesperson for Columbia confirmed the letter had gone out to students but declined to comment further.

Mahmoud Khalil, the lead negotiator on behalf of protesters, said university representatives began passing out the notices at the encampment shortly after 10 a.m. Monday. He said discussions were ongoing about how to proceed.

Early protests at Columbia, where demonstrators set up tents in the center of the campus, sparked pro-Palestinian demonstrations across the country. Students and others have been sparring over the Israel-Hamas war and its mounting death toll. Many students are demanding their universities cut financial ties with Israel.

About 275 people were arrested Saturday at various campuses including Indiana University at Bloomington, Arizona State University and Washington University in St. Louis. The number of arrests nationwide has surpassed 900 since New York police removed a pro-Palestinian protest encampment at Columbia and arrested more than 100 demonstrators on April 18.

The demonstrations at Columbia have led it to hold remote classes and set a series of deadlines for protesters to leave the encampment, which they have missed. The school said in an email to students that bringing back police “at this time” would be counterproductive.

The students and administrators have negotiated to end the disruptions, but the sides have not come to an agreement, university President Minouche Shafik said in a statement Monday.

Protests were still active at a number of campuses. Near George Washington University, protesters at an encampment breached and dismantled the barriers Monday morning used to secure University Yard, the university said in a statement. The yard had been closed since last week.

Protesters at Yale University set up a new encampment with dozens of tents Sunday afternoon, nearly a week after police arrested nearly 50 demonstrators and cleared a similar camp.

At least one school, the University of Southern California, canceled its main graduation ceremony this spring. Others are asking the protests to resolve peacefully so they can hold their ceremonies.

Protesters on both sides shouted and shoved each other during dueling demonstrations Sunday at the University of California, Los Angeles. The university stepped up security after “some physical altercations broke out among demonstrators,” Mary Osako, vice chancellor for UCLA Strategic Communications, said in a statement. There were no reports of arrests or injuries.

The plight of students who have been arrested has become a central part of protests, with the students and a growing number of faculty demanding amnesty for protesters. At issue is whether the suspensions and legal records will follow students through their adult lives.